Laser welding is a process that uses a focused laser beam to join two or more metal pieces together. It has many advantages over conventional welding methods, such as high precision, low heat input, minimal distortion, and high welding speed. Laser welding can weld multiple kinds of materials including dissimilar metals. In this article, we will introduce the basic principles, methods, techniques, advantages, and challenges of laser welding for dissimilar metals, such as aluminum, steel, titanium, and copper.
I. What is Dissimilar Metal Welding?
Dissimilar metal welding refers to welding processes that join metal pieces with different chemical compositions, physical properties, and metallurgical characteristics. Some examples of dissimilar metal pairs are aluminum/steel, aluminum/titanium, aluminum/copper, and steel/copper. These metal pairs are often used in hybrid structures or multi-materials that combine the best properties of each metal, such as strength, weight, corrosion resistance, electrical conductivity, and thermal conductivity.
However, welding dissimilar metals is not a simple task. There are some factors and challenges that need to be considered and addressed to ensure the formation of a strong, durable, and reliable joint. Some of these factors and challenges are:
1) Dilution and alloying:
During the welding of dissimilar metals, the metals will form a solid solution or a mixture of different phases in the weld pool. The composition and structure of the weld pool will depend on the amount of dilution or mixing of the base metals. Too much or too little dilution can affect the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of the joint.
2) Weldability level:
Weldability measures the capacity of one metal to be joined to another without cracking or other defects. When dissimilar metals are joined, there is a high risk of hot cracking or solidification cracking, which occurs when the weld pool cools and solidifies. Hot cracking is influenced by the melting point, thermal expansion, and solidification range of the metals.
3) Electrochemical characteristics:
During dissimilar metal welding, there is a risk of corrosion developing at the part of the joint where the metals transition from one to another (i.e., the intermetallic zone) or the weld surface itself. If the metals have significantly different electrochemical properties, such as potential, activity, or nobility, the corrosion risk is high. Corrosion can reduce the strength and durability of the joint and cause failure.
4) Melting point:
Different metals may melt at different temperatures. Therefore, the welder needs to use a welding process that quickly brings all metals to their melting points or a welding process that does not require any of them to melt. The melting point of the metals affects the heat input, welding speed, and power of the welding process.
5) Coefficient of thermal expansion:
Metals expand upon heating and contract upon cooling. Therefore, they change their shape and size when they are heated and cooled. The coefficient of thermal expansion measures how much a metal expands or contracts per unit of temperature change. If the metals have different coefficients of thermal expansion, they will experience different degrees of thermal stress and distortion during and after welding. This can cause cracking, warping, or misalignment of the joint.
II. How Does Laser Welding Work?
Laser welding is a type of fusion welding that uses a laser beam as the heat source to melt and join the metals. A laser beam is a coherent, monochromatic, and collimated beam of light that can be focused on a very small spot with high power density. The laser beam can be generated by different types of lasers, such as solid-state lasers, gas lasers, or fiber lasers. The laser beam can be delivered to the workpiece by different methods, such as direct irradiation, fiber optic cable, or mirror system.
The basic principle of laser welding is that the laser beam is focused on the joint area of the metals, where it creates a small and deep weld pool that rapidly solidifies. The laser beam can be moved along the joint line by moving the laser source, the workpiece, or both. The laser beam can be pulsed or continuous, depending on the welding parameters and requirements. The laser beam can also be modulated or manipulated by different techniques, such as defocusing, wobbling, or scanning, to improve the weld quality and performance.
There are two main modes of laser welding: conduction mode and keyhole mode. The mode of laser welding depends on the power density, welding speed, and material properties of the laser beam and the metals.
Conduction mode: Conduction mode is a low-power-density mode of laser welding, where the laser beam penetrates the surface of the metal and heats it by thermal conduction. The weld pool is shallow and wide, and the weld penetration is limited. Conduction mode is suitable for welding thin or heat-sensitive metals, such as aluminum or copper, or for welding dissimilar metals with low weldability or high cracking tendency, such as aluminum/steel or aluminum/titanium.
Keyhole mode: Keyhole mode is a high-power-density mode of laser welding, where the laser beam penetrates the metal and creates a vapor-filled cavity or keyhole in the weld pool. The keyhole acts as a waveguide that reflects and concentrates the laser beam, resulting in a deep and narrow weld pool and a high weld penetration. Keyhole mode is suitable for welding thick or high-melting-point metals, such as steel or titanium, or for welding dissimilar metals with high weldability or low cracking tendency, such as steel/copper or titanium/copper.
III. What are the Advantages of Laser Welding for Dissimilar Metals?
Laser welding has many advantages over conventional welding methods, such as arc welding, resistance welding, or brazing, for dissimilar metals, you can read Fiber Laser Welding: Advantages, Systems and Applications for details. Some of these advantages are:
1) High welding speed and productivity:
Laser welding can achieve high welding speeds, up to 10 m/min, depending on the power and mode of the laser beam and the thickness and type of the metals. This reduces the welding time and increases the productivity and efficiency of the welding process.
2) Low heat input and distortion:
Laser welding has a low heat input, as the laser beam is focused on a small area and the heat is quickly dissipated by the surrounding metal. This reduces the thermal stress and distortion of the joint and the heat-affected zone (HAZ), which is the area of the metal that is not melted but is affected by the heat of the welding process. A low heat input also reduces the risk of hot cracking and corrosion of the joint.
3) High weld quality and performance:
Laser welding can produce high-quality welds with a smooth and uniform appearance, a fine and homogeneous microstructure, and high weld strength and ductility. Laser welding can also achieve a high weld penetration and a low porosity and defect rate, which improves the performance and reliability of the joint.
4) High flexibility and versatility:
Laser welding can weld various types of dissimilar metals, such as aluminum, steel, titanium, and copper, with different thicknesses, shapes, and configurations. Laser welding can also weld metals that are difficult to weld by other methods, such as refractory metals, superalloys, or intermetallics. Laser welding can also weld metals that are sensitive to oxidation or contamination, such as titanium or aluminum, by using a shielding gas or a vacuum chamber to protect the weld pool from the atmosphere.
5) Low environmental impact and safety:
Laser welding has a low environmental impact, as it does not produce any smoke, fumes, sparks, or slag that can pollute the air or the workplace. Laser welding also has a low noise level and low energy consumption, which reduces the carbon footprint and the operating cost of the welding process. Laser welding also has a high safety level, as it does not involve any electrical current or flammable gas that can cause electric shock or fire hazards. However, laser welding requires proper eye and skin protection, as the laser beam can cause severe damage to the human body.
IV. What are the Challenges of Laser Welding for Dissimilar Metals?
Despite the many advantages of laser welding, there are also some challenges and limitations that need to be overcome to achieve successful and effective welding of dissimilar metals. Some of these challenges and limitations are:
1) Selection of welding parameters and techniques:
The selection of the appropriate welding parameters and techniques is crucial for laser welding of dissimilar metals, as they affect the weld quality, performance, and appearance. The welding parameters include the power, mode, speed, and focal position of the laser beam, the gap and offset of the joint, and the type and flow of the shielding gas. The welding techniques include the defocusing, wobbling, or scanning of the laser beam, the preheating or post-heating of the metals, and the use of filler materials or interlayers. The welding parameters and techniques need to be optimized and adjusted according to the type, thickness, and weldability of the metals, the joint configuration, and the welding requirements. Check the welding parameters of Megmeet RAY & LUX handheld and robotic laser welding machines.
2) Control of dilution and intermetallic formation:
The control of the dilution and the intermetallic formation is one of the most important and challenging aspects of laser welding of dissimilar metals, as they have a significant impact on the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of the joint. Dilution is the ratio of the base metal that is melted and mixed with the other base metal or the filler metal in the weld pool. Intermetallics are brittle and hard compounds that form in the weld pool or the intermetallic zone due to the chemical reaction between dissimilar metals. Both dilution and intermetallic formation depend on the welding parameters, such as the power, speed, and offset of the laser beam, and the material properties, such as the melting point, thermal expansion, and solubility of the metals. Too much or too little dilution can affect the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of the joint. Intermetallics can reduce the strength and ductility of the joint and increase the susceptibility to cracking and corrosion. Therefore, the welder needs to control the dilution and intermetallic formation by selecting the appropriate welding parameters and techniques, such as the power, speed, offset, and focal position of the laser beam, the use of filler materials or interlayers, and the preheating or post-heating of the metals.
3) Selection of joint design and configuration:
The selection of the joint design and configuration is another important and challenging aspect of laser welding of dissimilar metals, as it affects the weld quality, performance, and appearance. The joint design and configuration include the type, shape, size, and alignment of the joint, the gap and offset of the joint, and the position and direction of the laser beam. The joint design and configuration need to be compatible with the welding parameters and techniques, the material properties, and the welding requirements. Some of the common joint designs and configurations for laser welding of dissimilar metals are: Butt joint, Lap joint, T-joint.
4) Evaluation and testing of the joint:
The evaluation and testing of the joint is the final and essential step of laser welding of dissimilar metals, as it verifies the weld quality, performance, and appearance. The evaluation and testing of the joint can be done by different methods, such as visual inspection, microstructural analysis, mechanical testing, corrosion testing, and non-destructive testing. The evaluation and testing of the joint can reveal the defects, flaws, or failures of the joint, such as cracks, pores, inclusions, intermetallics, or corrosion. The evaluation and testing of the joint can also provide feedback and guidance for improving the welding parameters and techniques, the joint design and configuration, and the material selection and preparation.
V. Conclusion
Laser welding is a promising and advanced welding process that can join dissimilar metals with high quality, performance, and efficiency, but it also faces some challenges and difficulties that need to be addressed and solved to achieve successful and effective welding of dissimilar metals. By understanding and mastering the basic principles, methods, techniques, advantages, and challenges of laser welding for dissimilar metals we mentioned in this article, the welder can optimize and improve the welding process and the joint quality, performance, and appearance.
Related articles:
1. Fiber Laser Metal Welding Techniques Guide
2. What is Hybrid Laser-Arc Welding and How Does It Work?
3. What protective gas should I use for laser welding?
4. The Evolution of Laser Welding Technology
5. Laser Welding: Which Materials Can You Weld?
